Kaleidoscope: Indian American Youth Perspectives & Reflections

Heritage or Affection: Significance of Harris and Trump for Indian Americans this November

Tuesday, 01 Oct, 2024
(Photos courtesy: Kamala Harris/Official Portrait, Donald Trump/Facebook)

By Krishiv Shah 

New York, NY — There is no doubt that Indian-American representation in the American political sphere has increased significantly in recent years. Nikki Haley and Vivek Ramaswamy, both of Indian descent, competed for the 2024 Republican Presidential Nomination. 

Moreover, current Vice President Kamala Harris, who has Indian ancestry from Thulasendrapuram in Tamil Nadu, stands out as a prominent figure in American politics. 

According to AAPI Data, over half of eligible Indian American voters identify as Democrats or lean Democratic. This demographic shows strong support for issues like legalized abortion, gun control, and climate change, which positions them to favor Kamala Harris in upcoming elections. 

Harris takes pride in her dual heritage, stating that her relatives instilled in her a sense of pride in their South Asian roots. She grew up attending both a Black Baptist church and a Hindu temple, drawing significant inspiration from her mother, who, as an Indian immigrant, exemplified the pursuit of dreams. However, her identity has faced scrutiny from various quarters. Critics, including Republican leader Vivek Ramaswamy, have accused her of “using” her identity for political advantage, suggesting that she only embraces it when it is beneficial. 

For Indian American youth, witnessing someone with my background in a significant political role can be inspiring. Kamala Harris's navigation of her identity as a Black, Indian American illustrates her attempt to connect with diverse communities.

Former President Donald Trump has echoed criticisms, suggesting that Harris’s identity shifts are politically motivated, claiming she suddenly “turned Black” after previously identifying strongly with her Indian heritage. 

This raises broader questions about representation in American politics. The potential for someone of Indian origin to serve as President should not be viewed merely as a fulfillment of a diversity quota, but as a genuine representation of a diverse nation. Traditionally, many Indian families encourage careers in fields like medicine, engineering, or business. However, the growing visibility of Indian Americans in high political offices illustrates that individuals from our community can aspire to, and achieve, the highest levels of public service. 

The real question is whether Harris will truly represent the Indian American community. Many claim she only uses her identity when it is convenient. 

On the other hand, Trump has made efforts to garner the support of the Indian American diaspora. At the Namaste Trump Rally in February 2020, he stated, “America loves India, America respects India, and America will always be faithful and loyal friends to the Indian people.” This rhetoric has resonated with many Indian Americans. 

As we approach the upcoming election in November, I urge all eligible Indian Americans to conduct thorough research. Your primary concern should be who will best represent your interests, a significant aspect of which is your Indian American identity.
------------------


(Krishiv Shah, the founder and submission coordinator of Kaleidoscope, is an Indian-American senior at Syosset High School with aspirations to pursue a degree in South Asian Studies and Business.)